High-Yield Bonds: Yields Are Up, But Risks Remain
High-yield bonds have been one of the best-performing bond investments so far in 2023, but we continue to suggest a neutral view on the asset class.
Coming into the year, we were cautious on high-yield bonds given the risks of rising rates and tighter financial conditions. Investors generally have shrugged off those risks, pulling high-yield spreads down and prices up.
As we look forward, we maintain our cautious stance, but acknowledge that the rising likelihood of a "soft landing" may keep high-yield bond prices supported. While we don't necessarily expect it to happen, a soft landing—where growth slows enough to cool inflation, but the economy avoids recession—could prevent corporate profits and revenues from falling.
More importantly, the starting level of yields generally makes it harder for high-yield bonds to post a loss for a full year even if prices rise. High-yield bonds tend to offer high income payments, which can help offset potential price declines. The Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield Bond Index offers an average yield of roughly 8.5% which appears relatively attractive if investors plan to hold for a while and can ride out the ups and downs. Since 1990, there have been a total of 96 months during which the average yield of the index ended the month between 8% and 10%, and only 13 times has the index posted a negative return over the subsequent 12 months. A majority of those 12-month losses occurred during the 2008-2009 financial crisis, and all but four of the 13 negative returns were losses of 2.3% or less.
But we prefer investment-grade corporate bonds that have generally have A and BBB credit ratings1 and offer average yields that are close to 6% with much less credit risk than high-yield bonds.
The risks we have been highlighting are still present, and prices could fall in the next six to 12 months. While we still think there may be better entry points down the road, the yields currently offered have rarely been higher over the last 10 years. For those who are considering high-yield bonds today, we prefer those rated in the BB range as their prices would likely fall less than those rated B and CCC should the economy slow.
Risks are still present
High-yield bonds are those that have sub-investment-grade credit ratings—BB+ or below by Standard and Poor's or Fitch, or Ba1 or below by Moody's. They are also called "junk" bonds. They offer higher yields than many other bond investments because they come with additional risks.
High-yield bonds are issued by corporations that are generally deemed less creditworthy than those with investment-grade credit ratings. They might have too much debt relative to their earnings, or a very cyclical business model that results in volatile cash flows. With that sort of profile, there's a greater risk that the issuer won't be able to make timely interest or principal payments and ultimately may default on its debt obligations. That's a key reason why lower-rated issuers offer such high yields—they need to compensate investors for the risk that they might not get their money back as expected.
Another risk is that the compensation earned by investing in high-yield bonds is relatively low today. The extra yield that corporate bonds offer over comparable Treasuries is called a "spread" and it's currently well below its long-term average. The 10-year and 20-year average spreads of the Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield Bond Index are 4.3% and 5.0%, respectively, and the current spread is just 3.8%.
While the 20-year average includes the 2008-2009 financial crisis, which pulls up the average over that time frame, we can see in this chart below that spreads are volatile and can rise well above the current levels during periods of market stress or economic slowdowns.
High-yield spreads are below their long-term averages
Source: Bloomberg, using weekly data as of 8/25/2023.
Bloomberg US High-Yield Corporate Bond Index (LF98OAS Index). Option-adjusted spreads (OAS) are quoted as a fixed spread, or differential, over U.S. Treasury issues. OAS is a method used in calculating the relative value of a fixed income security containing an embedded option, such as a borrower's option to prepay a loan. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
We're also concerned that the aggressive pace of rate hikes and potential for slower growth could pull high-yield bond prices lower. When the yield curve is inverted like it is now—with shorter-term yields higher than longer-term yields—high-yield bonds tend to perform poorly relative to Treasuries. Since 1989, average excess returns for the Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield Bond Index have been negative when the three-month/10-year Treasury curve was inverted, and that yield curve is currently near its most inverted level in 40 years.
Average excess returns have been negative when the yield curve is inverted
Source: Bloomberg, using monthly data from August 1988 through July 2023.
Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield Bond Index (LF98TRUU Index) and Market Matrix US Sell 3 Month & Buy 10 Year Bond Yield Spread (USYC3M10 Index). Excess return is a measure of performance of a spread security over that of an equivalent Treasury security. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
A slowdown in bank lending or a tightening in lending standards also poses a risk to the high-yield bond market. The Federal Reserve's Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey tracks the lending and borrowing trends at banks. Over the last few quarters, we've seen banks generally tighten their lending standards for firms of all sizes and have generally raised the spread to lend to many companies. At the same time, demand for loans has generally declined.
Over time, high-yield spreads generally have risen when bank lending standards have tightened, but that hasn't necessarily been the case during this cycle.
Tighter bank lending standards have been accompanied by wider high-yield spreads in the past
Source: Bloomberg, using quarterly bank lending data as of 3Q 2023 and corporate spread data as of 8/25/2023.
Net % of Domestic Respondents Tightening Standards - C&I Loans for Large/Medium (SLDETIGT Index), Net % of Domestic Respondents Tightening Standards for C&I Loans for Small Firms (SLDETGTS Index), and Bloomberg US Corporate High Yield Bond Index Average OAS (LF98OAS Index). Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
There are a few reasons why high-yield bonds might not have followed historical trends. For one, the market has shrunk a bit lately as high-yield companies have looked elsewhere for financing opportunities. As a result, the amount outstanding of the Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield Bond Index has shrunk by more than $200 billion over the last two years, to $1.37 trillion from $1.59 trillion, a 13% decline. Meanwhile, the amount outstanding of the investment-grade-rated Bloomberg US Corporate Bond Index continues grow, and hit a new all-time high of $6.94 trillion on August 23, 2023.
This ties into the rise in private credit, which is one of those areas where high-yield bond companies may turn to for financing rather than issue in the public high-yield markets.
Finally, the types of default have shifted over the years. Distressed exchanges now make up a large share of corporate defaults these days. A distressed exchange is when an issuer preemptively negotiates with lenders to work out a deal in advance rather than filing for bankruptcy and working it out in the courts. Note that the negotiations are usually with large institutional investors, not with individual investors. These are still considered defaults because the lenders usually receive a "haircut" on their debt—meaning an amount less than the stated principal value—along with an extended maturity. But the outcomes may be better than leaving it to the courts while trying to figure out what the potential recovery value of the defaulted bond is. Unfortunately, according to Standard & Poor's, for companies that default through a "selective default," which includes a distressed exchange, there is a 35% likelihood that the issuer could default again in the next four years. In other words, a selective default doesn't necessarily solve the problems that the issuer may have.2
Focus on quality
Although we're still worried that the high-yield market as a whole can suffer price declines as the Fed's restrictive monetary policy stance works its way through the economy, those who are looking to invest for the long run and are interested in the yields that high-yield bonds offer should focus on those with the highest ratings within the high-yield rating spectrum.
Corporate bonds rated B and CCC tend to have the highest default rates, so we prefer high-yield bonds rated BB today. While we prefer a defensive approach to high-yield bonds for now, over time BB rated bonds tend to outperform B and CCC rated bonds, and with less volatility. Defaults have already begun to pick up lately. According to S&P, the trailing 12-month speculative grade default rate was 3.5% through the end of July, up from just 1.3% in July 2022, and it's expected to rise to 4.5% by June 2024.3
Over time, higher-rated high-yield bonds have outperformed those with lower ratings, and with less volatility
Source: Schwab Center for Financial Research with data provided by Bloomberg, as of 7/31/2023.
Average annualized total returns and standard deviations of the BB, B, and CCC sub-indexes of the Bloomberg U.S. Corporate High-Yield Bond Index (LF98TRUU Index) using monthly data from 7/31/2003 through 7/31/2023. Returns assume reinvestment of interest and capital gains. Indexes are unmanaged, do not incur management fees, costs and expenses (or "transaction fees or other related expenses"), and cannot be invested in directly. Standard deviation, commonly used as a measurement of risk, is a statistical measure that calculates the degree to which returns have fluctuated over a given time period. A higher standard deviation indicates a higher level of variability in returns. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
With defaults on the rise, we suggest investors who are considering high-yield bonds focus on the higher-rated parts of the market. They are less at risk of default and their prices should hold up better than those with lower ratings should the number of defaults pick up, as S&P expects.4
And like most bond yields lately, the average yields of BB rated bonds are up sharply and are currently at levels rarely seen over the last 12 years. But keep in mind that much of the recent rise in yields is due to the increase in Treasury yields rather than a rise in spreads. While BB rated bonds might not default frequently, their spreads would still likely rise over the short run should the economic growth outlook deteriorate.
BB rated corporate bonds currently offer average yields of more than 7%
Source: Bloomberg, using weekly data as of 8/25/2023.
Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield BB Bond Index (I00182US Index) reflects the performance of BB rated bonds within the Bloomberg US Corporate High-Yield Bond Index. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
What to do now
We're still cautious on high-yield bonds and believe the lagged effect of tight monetary policy should pull high-yield bond prices down over time. However, the better-than-expected economic data recently and the potential for a soft landing could keep high-yield bond prices supported. With higher starting yields today than what was available in late 2020 and 2021, positive total returns are still possible even if prices decline, as the rising coupon payments can help offset those declines.
We still believe high-yield bonds should underperform Treasuries and investment-grade corporates over the next 12 months. But from a long-term strategic standpoint, the 8.5% average yield that high-yield bonds currently offer represents a high starting point for investors who plan to hold for the long run and can ride out the ups and downs. For those willing to ride out those fluctuations, we favor high-yield bonds with BB ratings to help limit the downside.
1 The Moody's investment grade rating scale is Aaa, Aa, A, and Baa, and the sub-investment grade scale is Ba, B, Caa, Ca, and C. Standard and Poor's investment grade rating scale is AAA, AA, A, and BBB and the sub-investment-grade scale is BB, B, CCC, CC, and C. Ratings from AA to CCC may be modified by the addition of a plus (+) or minus (-) sign to show relative standing within the major rating categories. Fitch's investment-grade rating scale is AAA, AA, A, and BBB and the sub-investment-grade scale is BB, B, CCC, CC, and C.
2 Source: Standard and Poor's, "A Rise In Selective Defaults Presents A Slippery Slope", June 26, 2023.
3 Source: Standard and Poor's, "The U.S. Speculative-Grade Corporate Default Rate Could Rise To 4.5% By June 2024", August 17, 2023.